In Your Face Cheddar


This product is currently sold out.

Please fill in the form below if you'd like to be notified when it becomes available.

In Your Face Spicy 3 Pepper Cheddar Ingredients

Our award winning In Your Face spicy 3-pepper cheddar is one of our most popular flavors, telling us that many people do indeed like it HOT! Jalapeno, Habanero and sweet Red Peppers decorate In Your Face like confetti. This spicy 3-pepper cheddar is our spiciest cheese yet! Enjoy the heat!

Net Wt. 6 oz

How It's Made

In 2014, our In Your Face 3-Pepper Curds took 1st place in the only national cheese competition in North America (ACS Awards). These same curds are packed into 40 lb blocks and aged to create this seriously spicy cheddar.


Most people thing our pepper cheddar is hotter than our pepper jack even though we use the same three peppers in each. Why? Jack curds have the lactic acid rinsed from them and sit in a water bath, which creates a milder flavor and moist texture. Because of this, a Jack will coat your palate and cut the heat, while a sharper and drier cheddar allows the peppers to shine more.

Corn Tortillas, Limes, Tomatoes, Black Olives, Roasted Garlic, Cilantro & Shredded Meats


1st Place, 2015 LAIDC, Pepper-Flavored cheese.

3rd Place, 2019 ACS, Flavored Cheddar Category.

In Your Face Spicy 3 Pepper Cheddar Ingredients